Dallas Fed President Richard Fisher gave a great speech last week about ending “too big to fail” (TBTF) – the situation where a handful of banks are so large and important to the economic system that it is implicitly understood that the government would bail them out, rather than let them fail. Here are a few highlights (most of this is lifted straight from the speech or is slightly paraphrased):
1. TBTF defined. President Fisher defined TBTF as firms whose owners, managers and customers believe themselves to be exempt from the processes of bankruptcy and creative destruction.
2. Moral hazard. These firms are effectively subsidized (compared to their non-TBTF competitors) and the result is that they are likely to take greater risk in search of profits.
3. Hurting the recovery. These banks are limiting the effectiveness of monetary policy because sick banks don’t lend.
4. Ineffective regulatory solutions. Now, Dodd-Frank has 16 titles and runs 848 pages. More than 8,800 pages of regulations have been proposed (and we’re not done).
5. Dallas Fed’s solution to TBTF. The Dallas Fed believes that only commercial banking operations (not shadow banking facilities or the parent company) should benefit from the safety net of federal deposit insurance and access to the Fed’s discount window.
6. There are a few HUGE players. Approximately 98.6% (5,500 out of 5,600) of U.S. banking organizations are community banks with assets less than $10 billion. They only account for 12% of total industry assets. There are 70 banks with assets between $10 billion and $250 billion. They account for 1.2% of banks and 19% of assets. Finally, there are 12 institutions with assets between $250 billion and $2.3 trillion. These are .2% of all banks, but they hold 69% of industry assets. See chart below.
7. Little outside control over the TBTF banks. In comparing the different-size banks, President Fisher doesn’t believe that there’s much regulatory authority or investor control over the large banks. Because management does not believe that they would be allowed to fail, regulators have little control over the largest banks. Unsecured depositors and creditors offer their funds at a lower cost to TBTF banks than to mid-sized and regional banks that face the risk of failure. See chart below.
8. Huge financial subsidy. The TBTF global subsidy has been estimated as being worth $300 billion (annually) for the largest 29 banks. To put this in perspective, all the US bank holding companies summed together reported earnings of $108 billion in 2011.
9. Tremendously complex. See chart below to understand just how complex the five largest U.S. banks are.
10. More of the solution. We must reshape TBTF banking institutions into smaller, less-complex institutions that are economically valuable; profitable; competitively able to attract financial capital and talent; and of a size, complexity and scope that allows both regulatory and market discipline to restrain excessive risk taking.
11. Lets not penalize the majority of banks. At present, 99.8 percent of the banking organizations in the U.S. are subject to sufficient regulatory or shareholder/market discipline to contain the risk of misbehavior that could threaten the stability of the financial system. Zero-point-tow percent are not. Furthermore, to contain that risk, regulators and many small banks are tied up in regulatory and legal knots at an enormous direct cost to them and a large indirect cost to the economy.
12. We need an alternative solution. There should be more than the present two solutions: bailout or the end-of-the-economic-world-as-we-have-known-it. Both choices are unacceptable.
I love the fact that President Fisher is keeping the pressure up on this issue. Remember that President Fisher was the member of the FOMC who was saying that there were significant problems that were going to play out with our banks as the crisis started — see story here. While I tend to favor the required use of contingent convertible debt by banks (see my earlier blog post here), I’m just happy that we’re still talking about it.
Have a great week.
If you enjoy this blog, please forward it to others who may be interested.
If you want to receive these emails, here’s how:
1. click on this link (or type leedsonfinance.com into your browser)
2. toward the top right corner is a place to click on for email service — click and enter your email address
3. you will receive an email which will require you to click on a link to confirm that you want to be on the list
IMPORTANT: if you don’t receive the email in step 3 or you don’t click on the link, you won’t be on the list. Sometimes, people who use corporate emails get blocked (it’s probably 50% of the time). So if you don’t get the email, you know you need to use a personal email.